• Home >
  • Latest News >
  • Mutual Termination Agreements in Employment Law and the “Reasonable Benefit” Criterion

Mutual Termination Agreements in Employment Law and the "Reasonable Benefit" Criterion

You might find yourself facing a serious "reinstatement" lawsuit just when you believe you have mutually agreed to terminate an employment contract. If the "reasonable benefit" criterion—a legal requirement for mutual termination agreements—is not met, the signed agreements may be deemed invalid by the court, potentially resulting in severe financial penalties for your business.

Mutual termination agreements (*ikale* agreements)—which enable the termination of an employment contract through the mutual consent of the worker and the employer—are a frequently utilized method in labor law. However, the validity of such agreements is subject to strict rules established by the case law of the Court of Cassation.

For a mutual termination agreement to be deemed legally valid, it is essential that the worker’s intent is formed without any duress and that the worker receives a "reasonable benefit." Merely paying the amounts to which the worker is legally entitled—such as severance and notice pay—may not suffice to meet the "reasonable benefit" criterion; depending on the specific circumstances of the case, providing an additional payment or benefit to the worker may be required. Otherwise, courts may deem the signed agreement invalid, rule that the termination was unjust, and impose sanctions associated with reinstatement lawsuits upon the employer. Managing the mutual termination process transparently, fairly, and in compliance with legal requirements is imperative to safeguard the rights of both parties.